Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

...

...

...

Do NOT process any items that Michelle has crossed off. If she crossed them off, she is instructing you not to process them.


If the work is published, you should have the metadata record and work from the publisher's site

...

. Possibly you will also be working with with the work and metadata record on another site.

If you only have a file such as PDF, but no metadata record, web search to find the metadata record. If you have a metadata record but not a file, use the metadata record to open the file if possible. If the version of the file or the metadata record you have aren't the publisher's version, you should search the web to find them.

  • ResearchGate, Semantic Scholar, and Academia.edu are not publishers but for-profit businesses that allow people to post their works on them–they are never publishers.
  • Governments sites that compile works as a public service such as ERIC, eric.edu.gov, (works on education), Medline/PubMed, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/ (medical works), and the NASA Technical Report Server, https://www.sti.nasa.gov/ (NASA Publications and NASA employee publications) are not publishers, except the NASA Technical Report Server which is also a publisher for NASA works when NASA is given as the publisher on the record .
  • Other institutions' repositories aren't usually publishers (but sometimes are the publishers of journals and sometimes even books).
  • JSTOR is not a publisher, but hosts some journals for the publishers, and digitized back issues of journals. It is a fee-based resource, so we can't link to it, but if the publisher allows us to distribute the final published PDF, we use the PDF that's in JSTOR.
  • Preprint servers such as Arxiv, bioRxiv, medRxiv, and ESSOAr aren't publishers.
  • Personal and departmental websites aren't usually publishers (but sometimes departmental websites publish some of the department's works).
  • Google Docs or Drive aren't publishers (except very rarely when utilized by a publisher to post their works).

You should usually have both the work and a metadata record (possibly two of each) when you begin this procedure.

1A

Determine if the item is in scope for the repository and if it should be entered manually:

2A

Out of Scope (with exceptions noted): CV's, Obituaries, Patents, Abstracts with no Full Text, Theses and Dissertations

Cross these out on the print-out:

  • CV
  • Patent Application
  • Abstract with no full text document
  • Obituary unless the subject is affiliated with UMBC.
  • Description only of a grant funded project.
  • Theses or Dissertations:
    • Generally, if the item is a master thesis or PhD dissertation, or says Proquest Dissertation Publishing, we don't add manually–cross it off on the print-out.  UMBC thesis and dissertations are automatically sent to UMBC by Proquest and batch loaded, so don't add to a spreadsheet.
    • EXCEPTION: We don't receive any senior theses from Proquest, so these should be added to the spreadsheet and manually loaded.  Other institutions' master theses or PhD dissertations are out of scope. 

2B

About UMBC or an Author Affiliated with UMBC

  • There must be a UMBC author or alternately, the item must be about UMBC, a UMBC department, or person affiliated with UMBC. Often, the authors’ affiliation is included on the item. If not, use the UMBC directory, here, http://www.umbc.edu/search/directory// to to determine. If there is no UMBC author, and the subject is not UMBC, a UMBC department, or person, it's out of scope–cross of scope–cross it off on the print-out.

...

Notations on the Printout

...

Item is:

Notation is:

See also:

Out of scope

Cross it off

2B

duplicate of an item already in ScholarWorksCross it off and write "dup" next to it.
unpublishedunpublished7B

Available for free on web

Write ‘free’ next to it

3A

On a Creative Commons license

Write ‘CC license’ next to it

4A

U.S. Federal Government Publication

Write 'Fed gov doc' next to it

6A

In ArXiv (arxiv.org)

Write ‘arxiv’ next to it

6B

Published more than 20 years ago

Write ‘20+ years’ next to it

7A

Both a file and link can be added

Write ‘SS’ on the item

All sections in 8

Only a link can be added

Write ‘SS-link only’ on the item

All sections in 8

a book or book chapterWrite 'book' next to itAll Sections in 9
a conference paper, presentation, seminar, workshop or other conf eventWrite "conf" next to itAll Sections in 10
a conference presentation (slides)Write "conf pres" next to it

If you find a policy

Indicate which version(s) we can post per the policy (pre, post, publ). "No version" if we can't post anything.

See section immediately before 8 and 8

If you can't find a policyNo Policy

An Item for which you have or find the version we can post

Put a line through the versions noted when you add it to the spreadsheet

See section immediately before 8 and 8

An item you don't find or don't find a version we can post----------(make no notation)
UnlawfulAn item which is unlawfully posted, not abiding by the publisher's policy.




3A

U.S. Federal Government Publications

  • City, state, and county publications are not U.S. Federal Government publications. Items published by the United States government or written by employees of the United States government are U.S. Federal publications.
  • Federal government employees can be identified by the agency the author works for, or .gov in the author's email address.
  • Federal government agencies often have U.S. or national in their name, e.g. U.S. Department of Energy, National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA). They can also be identified by a .gov URL (see exceptions below). Sometimes, you simply have to know that it's a federal government agency, e.g. Smithsonian Institution, Los Alamos National Laboratory. 
  • Some common government agencies that we encounter are:
    • NOAA (National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, U.S. Department of Commerce)
    • The National Weather Service
    • NASA Goddard Flight Center and any other NASA (National Aeronatics and Space Adminstration) agencies
    • Army Research Labs
    • Navy Research Labs
    • NIST (National Institute of Standards and Technology, U.S. Department of Commerce)
    • CDC (Center for Disease Control and Prevention) and any CDC department or divisions
  • If you're not sure if a publisher is a U.S. federal government agency, google and look for the .gov in the URL. If the .gov is in the URL, it's a U.S. federal government agency.
  • The U.S. government is not the publisher of works on ERIC, eric.edu.gov, (works on education), Medline/PubMed, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/ (medical works), and the NASA Technical Report Server, https://www.sti.nasa.gov/ (NASA Publications and NASA employee publications), except for works on the NASA Technical Report Server where another publisher isn't given in the record for the item.
  • If the publisher is the United States Government or an agency of the federal government, or if an author is an employee of the U.S. Federal Government and did the work as part of their official job duties, the work can be added on a Creative Commons Public Domain license. Note "Fed Gov Doc" on the print-out, and skip to "Determine which collections to add an item to."
  • When filling in the spreadsheet, U.S. federal government publications get one of these rights notes. Choose the appropriate one: “This work was written as part of one of the author's official duties as an Employee of the United States Government and is therefore a work of the United States Government. In accordance with 17 U.S.C. 105, no copyright protection is available for such works under U.S. Law.” If the work is published by the U.S. Government, "This is a work of the United States Government. In accordance with 17 U.S.C. 105, no copyright protection is available for such works under U.S. Law." In either case, put on a public domain creative commons license.

...

  • The determination of whether an item is free is based on whether the publisher is making the item available for free or if the U.S. government is making an item available for free. There may be free versions posted elsewhere, but if an item is not free on the publisher's site, or in a U.S. government database, it's not free.
  • When working at home, any item you can access on the publisher's site or in a database without using the proxy server is free.
  • Items available for free in the U.S. government database, ERIC, eric.edu.gov, (works on education), Medline/PubMed, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/ (medical works), and the NASA Technical Report Server, https://www.sti.nasa.gov/ (NASA Publications and NASA employee publications), are free. Sometimes articles in these databases are free, and sometimes they're not free, so you have to figure this out.  A pubmed record may have a link icon that says free or  an attached pdf. When unsure if an item is free or not, simply try the links to find out.
  • When working in the library, materials in databases that UMBC subscribes to may appear free when they are not.  These are paywall protected pages where anyone accessing via UMBC IP ranges automatically is given access. Generally if there is a UMBC logo or mention of UMBC on the page, it's a subscription resource that is paywall protected. A list of UMBC paywall protected subscription resources that appear free is here: Vendors/Platforms that are Paywall Protected (this list is likely not complete–if come across something that needs to be added to it, let Michelle know). Individual items on paywall protected sites are free if the record explicitly states that the item is open access, available for free, or is on a Creative Commons license. Science Direct is a subscription database and not free, even though UMBC isn't mentioned on it, unless the record says it's Under an Elsevier user license, or Open Access, in which case that particular item is free. If Open Access, check for a Creative Commons license or terms.
  • If an item is free on the publisher's site or in a U.S. government database, write "free" next to it.

4B

Creative Commons License

  • Using the published version on the publisher's website, and the publisher's record, look for a Creative Commons license on the work itself or on its record. Note that if it's not free on the publisher's site, it is NOT on a Creative Commons license.If either says Creative Commons, the item can be added with both the publisher's file and a link to it.  Add on the same Creative Commons license that it was published on. Note "cc license" on the print-out and skip down to "Determine which collections to add an item to."

5A

Open Access

  • Using the published version on the publisher's website, and the publisher's record, look for"Open Access" on the work itself or it's record. Note that if it's not free on the publisher's site, it is NOT open access. If it says "Open Access", check the Policies on File document for the publisher. If it indicates that all of the publisher's works are on a Creative Commons license, note the license type, and follow the above steps for items on a Creative Commons license.

...

  • If you find that we can load the item either with both a file and link or just a link, skip down to "Determine which collections to add an item to."

6A

ArXiv

  • If an item is in ArXiv (https://arxiv.org/), and hasn't been published (items in Arxiv that have been published usually have a citation to the published version in the record) note "ArXiv" on the printout next to that item. If the item hasn't been published, we only need the UMBC author(s) permission to add the item to ScholarWorks@UMBC. 
  • If the item in Arxiv is a conference proceedings, be sure to search the conference and handle appropriately if trained to do so.
  • If you're working on a list of items that a faculty member asked us to load, we already have their permission for unpublished work in Arxiv and don't need to ask permission to load--both a file and a link to the file in ArXiv can be included. Skip to "Determine which collections to add an item to."
  • If we're working on items the faculty hasn't asked us to load, like Google Alerts,  we need to ask the author for permission to load works that are in Arxiv, Michelle will do this when she gets the printout back from you.
  • If the item  is in Arxiv has been published, it should be handled like any other work starting with step 4A above. 

C

Check rights to determine if we can add files, links, or both

All items that we add must be available to the user for free, either because we provide a file the user can access, or because we provide a link to the publisher's website where the item is available for free.

...


...

7A

Items more than 20 years old

  • If it's available for free on the web, add with a link only, and write "20+ years" next to it. 

7B

Determining if an Item is Unpublished

If there is no indication anywhere that an item has ever been published, write "unpublished" next to it. Technical reports are typically unpublished, although if issued by an agency, the agency should be considered the publisher. If we have the author's permission to load, skip down to "Determine which collections to add an item to."

8A 

Vocab for Checking Rights

Vocab


Preprint

Postprint

Final Published Version

also calledsubmitted versionaccepted versionversion of record (VOR)
definitionthe version the author originally submitted to the publisherthe version the author submitted to the publisher after making changes based on peer reviewer commentsthe version of the article in the publisher's database or on their website
characteristicsNo copyright statement, no publisher's logo, no page numbering that begins with a number larger than 1No copyright statement, no publisher's logo, no page numbering that begins with a number larger than 1Copyright statement, publisher's logo, page numbering that begin with a number larger than 1
  • If the work or record states what version it is, that is what it is.
  • If you can't determine whether something is a preprint or postprint, assume that it's the version that you can post. If you can post either, assume that it's a preprint
  • A publisher's proof isn't isn't a preprint, postprint, or final published version. We don't accept these.

7A

Items more than 20 years old

  • If it's available for free on the web, add with a link only, and write "20+ years" next to it. 

7B

Determining if an Item is Unpublished

If there is no indication anywhere that an item has ever been published, write "unpublished" next to it. Technical reports are typically unpublished, although if issued by an agency, the agency should be considered the publisher. If we have the author's permission to load, skip down to "Determine which collections to add an item to."

Checking Resources

...

  • A publisher's proof isn't isn't a preprint, postprint, or final published version. We don't accept these.

...

8B

Check rights to determine if we can add files, links, or both

All items that we add must be available to the user for free, either because we provide a file the user can access, or because we provide a link to the publisher's website where the item is available for free.

  • The distribution of files is governed by copyright law. Therefore when adding files we need to abide by publisher's policies, usually available in the "Policies on File Document," the "Sherpa-Romeo database, or on the journal or publishers website. When adding a file, a link to the final published version of an item should always also be included even if the final published version is behind a paywall.
  • If if we can't post the file but the item is available for free on the publisher's site, it can be posted with a link only, as copyright law doesn't apply to links. Link-only is decided based on if an item is free on the publisher's site. Copyright law and publisher's policies are not relevant to link only items.
  • If we can't post a file and the item is not free, we only record a note on the print-out saying what version is needed.

8B

  • Check the Policies on File document for the publisher. If you don't find it, go to the next step. If the item is a journal article, also check Sherpa Romeo, and if you find it in Sherpa Romeo, process in accordance with the Sherpa-Romeo policy. If you find the publisher, determine what version or versions  that we can post. Note this next to the item. Then determine if the version you have is a version we can post. Note that this is usually not stated, but you have to figure it out. If the version you have is a version that we can post, add it to your spreadsheet (including all terms), crossing off the version notations and writing SS on the item. If the version we have is a version that we're not allowed to post, note "unlawfully posted" next to the item.


Journal Articles Only

8B

  • IF the item you have is a journal article, Check SHERPA/RoMEO, http://www.sherpa.ac.uk/romeo/index.php, for the journal. If you don't find it, go to the next step. If you find the journal, determine what version or versions of the article that we can post. Note this next to the item. Then determine if the version you have is a version we can post. Note that this is usually not stated, but you have to figure it out. If the version you have is a version that we can post, add it to your spreadsheet (including all terms), crossing off the version notations and writing SS on the item. If the version we have is a version that we're not allowed to post, note "unlawfully posted" under the item. 

...

  • If the item is a journal article and free on the publisher's website, and you didn't find any info above, add it with only a link to the item on the publisher's website. 

8F 

No Policy

If you don't find a policy, write "no policy: " next to the item. If it is free, add it "link only.

...